Issue Details (XML | Word | Printable)

Key: STYLE-130
Type: New Feature New Feature
Status: Reopened Reopened
Priority: Normal Normal
Assignee: Unassigned
Reporter: Valeriy Orlov
Votes: 5
Watchers: 4
Available Workflow Actions

RFC Sent
Operations

If you were logged in you would be able to see more operations.
MusicBrainz Style

Addition of the signs (attributes) "probably" and "either... or" to relationships

Created: 24/Dec/11 07:25 AM   Updated: 19/Nov/12 10:53 PM  Due: 05/Jul/12
Component/s: Relationships
Affects Version/s: None
Fix Version/s: None

Issue Links:
Relates
 


 Description  « Hide

In many cases some recording details remain uncertain. Examples:
1) probably Specled Red on piano;
2) John Smith or Peter James on drums;
3) recorded possibly in (near) 1957;
4) recorded in March 13 or December 21, 1959.
Now in all similar cases we can not reflect correctly this information.
For the case (1) we have three possibilities:
a) do not mention neither Speckled Red nor piano;
b) mention "unknown on piano";
c) mention "Speckled Red performs on piano" as established fact.
Each of these variants is a poor choice.
For the case (2) we can:
a) mention "John Smith performs on drums" and "Peter James performs on drums";
b) mention only "John Smith performs on drums";
c) mention only "Peter James performs on drums";
d) mention "unknown on drums";
e) do not mention neither drums nor drummer.
Each of these variants is a poor choice.
And so on.

Sort Order: Ascending order - Click to sort in descending order
Valeriy Orlov made changes - 24/Dec/11 07:27 AM
Field Original Value New Value
Description In many cases some recording details remain uncertain. Examples:
1) probably Specled Red on piano;
2) John Smith or Peter James on drums;
3) recorded possibly in (near) 1957;
4) recorded in March 13 or December 21, 1959.
Now in all similar cases we can not reflect correctly this information.
For the case (1) we have two possibilities:
a) do not mention Speckled Red;
b) mention "Speckled Red performs on piano" as established fact.
Each of these variants is a poor choice.
For the case (2):
a) mention "John Smith performs on drums" and "Peter James performs on drums";
b) mention only "John Smith performs on drums";
c) mention only "Peter James performs on drums".
Each of these three variants is a poor choice.
And so on.
    		In many cases some recording details remain uncertain. Examples:
1) probably Specled Red on piano;
2) John Smith or Peter James on drums;
3) recorded possibly in (near) 1957;
4) recorded in March 13 or December 21, 1959.
Now in all similar cases we can not reflect correctly this information.
For the case (1) we have two possibilities:
a) do not mention Speckled Red;
b) mention "Speckled Red performs on piano" as established fact.
Each of these variants is a poor choice.
For the case (2):
a) mention "John Smith performs on drums" and "Peter James performs on drums";
b) mention only "John Smith performs on drums";
c) mention only "Peter James performs on drums";
d) do not mention any drummer.
Each of these variants is a poor choice.
And so on.
   
Valeriy Orlov made changes - 24/Dec/11 07:35 AM
Summary Addition of the signs "probably" and "either... or" to relationships Addition of the signs (attributes) "probably" and "either... or" to relationships
Description In many cases some recording details remain uncertain. Examples:
1) probably Specled Red on piano;
2) John Smith or Peter James on drums;
3) recorded possibly in (near) 1957;
4) recorded in March 13 or December 21, 1959.
Now in all similar cases we can not reflect correctly this information.
For the case (1) we have two possibilities:
a) do not mention Speckled Red;
b) mention "Speckled Red performs on piano" as established fact.
Each of these variants is a poor choice.
For the case (2):
a) mention "John Smith performs on drums" and "Peter James performs on drums";
b) mention only "John Smith performs on drums";
c) mention only "Peter James performs on drums";
d) do not mention any drummer.
Each of these variants is a poor choice.
And so on.
    		In many cases some recording details remain uncertain. Examples:
1) probably Specled Red on piano;
2) John Smith or Peter James on drums;
3) recorded possibly in (near) 1957;
4) recorded in March 13 or December 21, 1959.
Now in all similar cases we can not reflect correctly this information.
For the case (1) we have two possibilities:
a) do not mention neither Speckled Red nor piano;
b) mention "unknown on piano";
c) mention "Speckled Red performs on piano" as established fact.
Each of these variants is a poor choice.
For the case (2):
a) mention "John Smith performs on drums" and "Peter James performs on drums";
b) mention only "John Smith performs on drums";
c) mention only "Peter James performs on drums";
d) mention "unknown on drums";
e) do not mention neither drums nor drummer.
Each of these variants is a poor choice.
And so on.
   
Valeriy Orlov made changes - 24/Dec/11 07:36 AM
Description In many cases some recording details remain uncertain. Examples:
1) probably Specled Red on piano;
2) John Smith or Peter James on drums;
3) recorded possibly in (near) 1957;
4) recorded in March 13 or December 21, 1959.
Now in all similar cases we can not reflect correctly this information.
For the case (1) we have two possibilities:
a) do not mention neither Speckled Red nor piano;
b) mention "unknown on piano";
c) mention "Speckled Red performs on piano" as established fact.
Each of these variants is a poor choice.
For the case (2):
a) mention "John Smith performs on drums" and "Peter James performs on drums";
b) mention only "John Smith performs on drums";
c) mention only "Peter James performs on drums";
d) mention "unknown on drums";
e) do not mention neither drums nor drummer.
Each of these variants is a poor choice.
And so on.
    		In many cases some recording details remain uncertain. Examples:
1) probably Specled Red on piano;
2) John Smith or Peter James on drums;
3) recorded possibly in (near) 1957;
4) recorded in March 13 or December 21, 1959.
Now in all similar cases we can not reflect correctly this information.
For the case (1) we have three possibilities:
a) do not mention neither Speckled Red nor piano;
b) mention "unknown on piano";
c) mention "Speckled Red performs on piano" as established fact.
Each of these variants is a poor choice.
For the case (2) we can:
a) mention "John Smith performs on drums" and "Peter James performs on drums";
b) mention only "John Smith performs on drums";
c) mention only "Peter James performs on drums";
d) mention "unknown on drums";
e) do not mention neither drums nor drummer.
Each of these variants is a poor choice.
And so on.
   
Oliver Charles made changes - 27/Feb/12 01:05 PM
Status Open [ 1 ] Decision Required [ 10000 ]
Jacob Brett made changes - 20/Mar/12 07:02 AM
Link This issue has related issue MBS-1385 [ MBS-1385 ]
Oliver Charles made changes - 26/Jun/12 07:27 PM
Component/s Schema Change [ 10065 ]
Nicolás Tamargo made changes - 26/Jun/12 07:36 PM
Project MusicBrainz Server [ 10000 ] MusicBrainz Style [ 10032 ]
Key MBS-4059 STYLE-130
Component/s Relationships [ 10042 ]
Component/s Release editor [ 10002 ]
Component/s Schema Change [ 10065 ]
Nicolás Tamargo made changes - 26/Jun/12 07:38 PM
Status Decision Required [ 10000 ] Closed [ 6 ]
Resolution RFC Required [ 7 ]
patate12 made changes - 28/Jun/12 12:55 PM
Resolution RFC Required [ 7 ]
Status Closed [ 6 ] Reopened [ 4 ]
Nicolás Tamargo made changes - 30/Jun/12 08:50 AM
Due Date 2012-07-05 00:00:00.0
nikki made changes - 01/Dec/12 01:23 PM
Workflow MusicBrainz [ 14872 ] Style [ 17135 ]
Atlassian JIRA (v4.0.1#471) | Report a problem | Request a feature | Contact administrators
Powered by a free Atlassian JIRA open source license for MetaBrainz Foundation. Try JIRA - bug tracking software for your team.