What we have now is a huge improvement, but to make it perfect, it should go back to the Overview tab (the one where the relationships are shown) after adding one even if I do it from the Alias tab
Agreed to fix within 3 months in #musicbrianz-devel and through the scheduling game.
Is this still a valid ticket?
After I create a relationship to a recording I end up on the recording's overview page. Am I missing something?
Haven't tried with recordings, but if I add a relationship to a work starting from it's Alias tab, I end back in the Alias tab and I can't see the rel I just added.
The obvious methods aren't working for me, I'll leave this for the powers that be to deal with
This is in conflict with the comment at http://tickets.musicbrainz.org/browse/MBS-2117?focusedCommentId=13933&page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels%3Acomment-tabpanel#action_13933, which is the current implementation. One possible solution is to not redirect the user back to the page they were on, but infact redirect them back to the /mbid page.
I'd say that ticket is about a completely different issue. Of course people would expect to be brought back to the same artist they were in and not taken to other artist. But to the page they were in inside the entity, or to the page that shows some useful info about the thing they just entered? I'd say the latter...
Decision is to redirect back to the overview tab.
Who decided that? It doesn't make any sense for artists or labels because relationships are not shown on the overview tab for those. The whole point is to go to the page where the relationships are shown so that you can see what you just added.
A meeting somewhere. Generalising to "the page where relationships are" sounds fine.
In review at http://codereview.musicbrainz.org/r/2218/
This has failed beta testing, so I have reopened it (due to MBS-5277).
Now in review again at http://codereview.musicbrainz.org/r/2218/
The merge window for 2012-10-01 is now closed, so this will have to wait until 2012-10-15.