[#MBS-2467] RE: Add Missing Entities problems with caps - MusicBrainz JIRA

MusicBrainz Server

RE: Add Missing Entities problems with caps

Created: 01/Jun/11 10:50 AM Updated: 14/Oct/11 07:08 PM Resolved: 14/Oct/11 11:15 AM

Component/s:

Release editor, User interface

Affects Version/s:

Bug fixes, 2011-06-01

Fix Version/s:

Bug fixes, 2011-10-10

File Attachments:

None

Image Attachments:

1. srsly.png
(148 kB)

Issue Links:

Relates

This issue is related to:

~~MBS-3208~~ Trim leading/trailing whitespace in release editor prior to Add Missing Entities check

This issue has related issue:

~~MBS-3635~~ Internal server error when adding a release "No artists was created for foo"

~~MBS-2817~~ Add Missing Entities not displaying correct search results for many artists

MBS-3422 Release editor > Advanced mode > Guess case is wrongly applied to track artists

Description

« Hide

Add Missing Entities wants me to add an artist twice because I entered it without caps in the first step (what the band uses) and then it decided to use it with caps too (I guess because of Guess Case in the tracklist). This makes little sense, and it doesn't allow me to just add one of them and use it for all.

Sort Order:

[ Permalink | « Hide ]

Kuno Woudt added a comment - 07/Jun/11 01:44 PM

What if the user did intend for two different artists to be added, how do you propose that should be handled?

Kuno Woudt made changes - 07/Jun/11 01:45 PM

Field	Original Value	New Value
Fix Version/s		Bug fixes, 2011-06-13 [ 10078 ]
Affects Version/s		Bug fixes, 2011-06-01 [ 10076 ]
Component/s		User interface [ 10060 ]

Kuno Woudt made changes - 07/Jun/11 01:45 PM

Status

Open [ 1 ]

Decision Required [ 10000 ]

[ Permalink | « Hide ]

Nicolás Tamargo added a comment - 07/Jun/11 01:48 PM

What is the chance of a same release featuring two different bands, the only difference between their names being the capitalization?

Oliver Charles made changes - 14/Jun/11 09:51 PM

Fix Version/s		Bug fixes, 2011-06-20 [ 10079 ]
Fix Version/s	Bug fixes, 2011-06-13 [ 10078 ]

voiceinsideyou made changes - 19/Jun/11 04:39 PM

Link

This issue has related issue ~~MBS-2817~~ [ ~~MBS-2817~~ ]

[ Permalink | « Hide ]

voiceinsideyou added a comment - 19/Jun/11 04:52 PM

My vote is for this to be case insensitive as suggested by Nicolás; although not sure if there are wider internationalization concerns here. In the very small number of cases where it's intentional (perhaps some weird artist intent where the different capitalization is intentional) I think requiring a post-addition edit would be acceptable.

[ Permalink | « Hide ]

Aurélien Mino added a comment - 20/Jun/11 10:51 PM

I encountered this exact issue and have pested against release editor.
I ended creating the new artist outside release editor, then reloading the Add Missing Entities tab.

Oliver Charles made changes - 21/Jun/11 01:54 PM

Fix Version/s		Bug fixes [ 10080 ]
Fix Version/s	Bug fixes, 2011-06-20 [ 10079 ]

nikki made changes - 24/Jun/11 12:14 AM

Fix Version/s		NGS + 1 [ 10070 ]
Fix Version/s	Bug fixes, 2011-07-04 [ 10080 ]

[ Permalink | « Hide ]

Oliver Charles added a comment - 02/Aug/11 09:47 AM

Agreed, this is so edge-case that case insensitive is the way to go

voiceinsideyou made changes - 10/Aug/11 03:07 AM

Link

This issue is related to ~~MBS-3208~~ [ ~~MBS-3208~~ ]

[ Permalink | « Hide ]

voiceinsideyou added a comment - 16/Sep/11 09:28 AM

We should move forward on this I think; it's really annoying. (see MBS-3422)

voiceinsideyou made changes - 16/Sep/11 09:28 AM

Assignee

Kuno Woudt [ warp ]

Robert Kaye [ rob ]

voiceinsideyou made changes - 16/Sep/11 09:30 AM

Link

This issue has related issue MBS-3422 [ MBS-3422 ]

[ Permalink | « Hide ]

Robert Kaye added a comment - 19/Sep/11 10:46 PM

Yes, lets go with case insensitive.

Robert Kaye made changes - 19/Sep/11 10:46 PM

Status	Decision Required [ 10000 ]	Open [ 1 ]
Assignee	Robert Kaye [ rob ]	Oliver Charles [ acid2 ]
Fix Version/s		Bug fixes, 2011-09-26 [ 10102 ]
Fix Version/s	NGS + 1 [ 10070 ]

Oliver Charles made changes - 20/Sep/11 12:16 PM

Status

Open [ 1 ]

Review Submitted [ 5 ]

Oliver Charles made changes - 20/Sep/11 12:16 PM

Fix Version/s		Bug fixes, 2011-09-19 [ 10101 ]
Fix Version/s	Bug fixes, 2011-09-26 [ 10102 ]

Oliver Charles made changes - 21/Sep/11 02:42 PM

Fix Version/s		Bug fixes, 2011-09-26 [ 10102 ]
Fix Version/s	Bug fixes, 2011-09-19 [ 10101 ]

Oliver Charles made changes - 03/Oct/11 09:26 PM

Fix Version/s		Bug fixes, 2011-10-03 [ 10103 ]
Fix Version/s	Bug fixes, 2011-09-26 [ 10102 ]

Oliver Charles made changes - 14/Oct/11 11:15 AM

Status	Review Submitted [ 5 ]	Closed [ 6 ]
Resolution		Fixed [ 1 ]

voiceinsideyou made changes - 14/Oct/11 07:08 PM

Link

This issue has related issue ~~MBS-3635~~ [ ~~MBS-3635~~ ]